order online/Schwartzfamilyrestaurant

Take Home
Fresh-Baked-Amish-Style
Delights

Made from Scratch Pies, Cakes, Breads, Rolls and Cookies

are available for your next celebration or just-because dinner.

Photo: Lemon Meringue Pie

Ordering Directions

1. Choose a pickup date and time.
2. Follow Prompts and Make Selections.
3. Baked Goods require a 5-day lead time.
4. Add "Special Notes" at the end of your order.
(We offer Holiday Dinner Carry Out orders during particular times of the year.)
Dinners can be purchased To-Go in the restaurant throughout the year.

We are now closed, you can still place a future order.

Pickup, ASAP (in 3 days)

Pies Cakes Baked Goods

Bakery Pies Cakes Baked Goods

Bakery

Pies

All of our pies start with a made-from-scratch crust. Those flaky crusts are filled with our secret recipes and homemade fillings. They are prepared and baked fresh in our kitchen. Pies serve 8

Our banana cream pie is an old-fashioned favorite. We make our rich creamy filling in a saucepan and poured it into our special crust with bananas, whipped cream a few nuts to top it all off.

14.00 USD

*Blackberry pie made from scratch and topped with our delicious crumble. Served year-round. *Blackberries are picked fresh from our farm and reserved for our pies all year long.

14.00 USD

Our made-from-scratch Blueberry cream pie is heaven in each bite. *We use fresh blueberries picked from our farm for each of our pies. When combined with the creamy custard, it is simply delicious.

14.00 USD

We top our creamy butterscotch pie with fresh hand-whipped cream and a caramel drizzle. Our homemade butterscotch doesn't come from a box. It is made with wholesome ingredients from our kitchen.

14.00 USD

Cherry pie has a perfect balance of sweet and tart wrapped in our homemade flaky pie crust.

14.00 USD

Deliciously creamy chocolate pie. It is topped with a sweet fluffy topping and freshly grated chocolate. Ours is always made from scratch pie crust and filling.

14.00 USD

Our made from scratch Coconut Cream Pie is the answer to creamy sweet delight with a toasted coconut topping and flaky pie crust.

14.00 USD

We make our Creamy Custard Pie with cream, sugar, eggs, and vanilla with a bit of cartelized sugar on top. It is a simple yet delicious dessert.

14.00 USD

Our made-from-scratch Derby pie has just the right mix of coconut, chocolate chips, and oatmeal. You can serve it cold or warm it up for a simply delicious treat.

14.00 USD

Our made-from-scratch Dutch Apple pie is perfectly sweet, made with fresh apples and a crumbly topping of sugar, cinnamon, butter, flour, and oats is simply delicious when you take home and warm it up.

14.00 USD

We make our pies fresh and from scratch. The homemade flaky crust is filled with sweet and tart lemon custard and is topped with fluffy meringue topping.

14.00 USD

We make our pies fresh and from scratch. Homemade flaky crust and a delicious peach pie filling with just the right amount of sugar.

14.00 USD

We make our Pecan Pies with fresh pecans, sugar, syrup, butter, and a flaky pie crust.

14.00 USD

Our creamy Peanut butter custard doesn't come from a box - it's made in a saucepan with our homemade peanut butter, sugar, cream, butter, and lots of yumminess. It is topped with fluffy whipped cream all atop our flaky pie crust.

14.00 USD

Homemade flaky crust and a delicious pie filling with just the right amount of sugar and spices. We make our pies fresh and from scratch.

14.00 USD

Raisin Pie originated in Amish and Mennonite communities. Our made from scratch raisin pie won't disappoint pie lovers. This is one pie you can't get made fresh everywhere.

14.00 USD

Our pie is fresh. The strawberries are grown in our patch near the restaurant and picked daily. We placed in one of our made-from-scratch pie crusts with a few more secret ingredients and topped it with homemade whipped cream.

16.00 USD

Cakes

All of our desserts are made from scratch at the restaurant. Our cakes are made from scratch with wholesome ingredients and freshly made buttercream frosting. Pies serve 8

Made from scratch - double layers of chocolate cake and icing. Order a whole cake for your next special birthday or special occasion. (16 slices)

24.00 USD

Made from scratch - double layers of freshly grated carrots, and chopped nuts. Our cake is topped with our house-made cream cheese icing and nuts. Order a whole cake for your next special birthday or special occasion. (16 slices)

24.00 USD

Made from scratch - fine cake flour and lots of freshly whipped egg whites along with sugar make this cake light and fluffy. It melts in your mouth with each bite. This cake can be ordered uniced or with our fresh whipped cream topping and choice of blackberry or cherry layered filling. Order a whole cake for your next special birthday or special occasion. (16 slices)

14.00 USD