top of page
Holiday Dinner Horizontal-1.png

Online Ordering

Select pickup date and time, choose from our delicious menu, and let us handle the rest.

Accepting Orders
Min. order - $1.00
Pickup time: Sep 23, 2:30 PM - 3:00 PM
Pickup Address: 6738 West Governors Trace, Eckerty, IN 47116

Entrée and Sides

Homestyle Entrée Favorites

Choose from any of our freshly made entrées. All are prepared in oven-ready trays, refrigerated, and ready to reheat or bake to perfection at home.

Lasagna

Enjoy a hearty dish of family-style lasagna: cheese, ground beef, noodles, and red sauce piping hot and delicious. You can request it unbaked! Just make sure to choose that option when you check out.

$25.00

Lasagna

Meat Loaf

Enjoy 100% beef seasoned just like Grandma's meatloaf, topped with a special ketchup sauce that balances tomato and sweetness. This delicious meatloaf comes packaged as a whole, pre-cooked loaf, ready for reheating (instructions included). Prefer to bake at home? You can request it unbaked! Just make sure to choose that option when you check out.

$25.00

Meat Loaf

Roast Beef

Our slow-roasted beef is perfectly seasoned with a blend of homestyle spices and served with made-from-scratch beef gravy. You can add more savory gravy if you choose to have extra for drizzling over our homemade mashed potatoes and dinner rolls, enhancing your meal experience.

$25.00

Roast Beef

BBQ Pork

Our slow-roasted pork butts are hand-shredded and topped with a slightly sweet hickory smoked BBQ sauce. Take home, heat, and eat!

$25.00

BBQ Pork
Specialty Sides

Specialty Sides

Our specialty sides are our recipes chocked full of flavor and creaminess.

Amish Buttered Noodles

Our delicious, made-from-scratch noodles start with farm-fresh eggs from our hens. Rolled out and cut just for you, they’re cooked to perfection and simply buttered, making them ready for you to enjoy at home!

$15.00

Amish Buttered Noodles

Chicken & Dumplings

Enjoy delicious, made-from-scratch chicken and dumplings that are cooked to perfection and seasoned just right! Juicy chicken and plump dumplings come together as a homestyle comfort food that everyone can savor.

$15.00

Chicken & Dumplings

Broccoli Cauliflower Casserole

Dive into this delightful casserole! A cozy mix of tender broccoli and cauliflower, all wrapped in creamy, cheesy goodness. It's the perfect dish for gatherings or a comforting weeknight family dinner. Enjoy every bite!

$15.00

Broccoli Cauliflower Casserole

Sour Cream Cheese Potatoes

This specialty side is a creamy blend of cheese, sour cream, cream cheese, and hand-peeled potatoes, creating an elevated potato experience.

$15.00

Sour Cream Cheese Potatoes

Mac - n - Cheese

Made-from-Scratch Mac & Cheese Creamy, cheesy, and comforting — our mac and cheese is made the old-fashioned way,. We stir in generous handfuls of real cheddar into tender elbow macaroni. Every bite is loaded with homemade goodness — no boxes, no shortcuts, just real comfort food from scratch.

$15.00

Mac - n - Cheese

Sweet Potato Casserole

You won't find this sweet potato casserole anywhere else! Made with hand-peeled sweet potatoes, marshmallows, cinnamon, and eggs, it’s a delightful treat. Topped with a delicious crumble of pecans and sugar, it’s simply irresistible.

$15.00

Sweet Potato Casserole
Traditional Sides

Traditional Sides

Choose from delicious vegetable sides that include corn grown on our farm.

Corn

Our corn is like none other! Harvested from our farm patch, it's shucked, blanched, and preserved exclusively for our restaurant. This tender, sweet corn is perfectly seasoned and ready to serve your guests.

$11.00

Corn

Green Beans

Savory green beans with onion and bacon are a delicious addition to any luncheon, family dinner, or holiday meal.

$11.00

Green Beans

Chicken Dressing

Our dressing features made-from-scratch bread and juicy chicken, all enhanced by a blend of herbs. Baked to a golden brown, it’s the perfect addition to your dinner.

$11.00

Chicken Dressing

Mashed Potatoes

**Please order gravy separately.** Enjoy our delicious, made-from-scratch mashed potatoes, hand-peeled and perfectly smashed. They’re ready to accompany our gravy, noodles, roast beef, or be savored on their own.

$11.00

Mashed Potatoes

Gravy

Enhance your meal with our made-from-scratch gravy, ideal for drizzling over mashed potatoes, rolls, turkey, roast beef, and dressing. Choose the perfect amount to complement your favorites and elevate your meal. **Beef Gravy** Turkey Gravy is available with your order of turkey.

$6.00

Gravy
Salads

Salads

Our creamy salads are made fresh daily with our own recipe.

Coleslaw

Fresh-made in-house creamy coleslaw.

$5.50

Coleslaw

Potato Salad

We use our special Amish recipe for our freshly homemade Potato Salad. We start with hand-peeled potatoes, adding sweet bread and butter pickles, onions, and eggs. Each bite is a taste of tradition and comfort!

$5.50

Potato Salad

Macaroni Salad

Enjoy our homemade macaroni salad! It's a perfect blend of sweet and tangy, with just the right touch of vinegar and sugar. Crunchy celery and pickles add texture, all wrapped around comforting macaroni. You won't be disappointed!

$5.50

Macaroni Salad

Bakery

Enjoy our made-from-scratch desserts and baked goods year-round. Whole desserts must be ordered at least four days before your pick-up date.

Pies

Pies

All of our pies start with a made-from-scratch crust. Those flaky crusts are filled with our secret recipes and homemade fillings. They are prepared and baked fresh in our kitchen. Pies serve 8

Banana Cream Pie

Our banana cream pie is a classic favorite. We prepare a rich, creamy filling in a saucepan and pour it into our special crust, layering it with bananas, whipped cream, and a sprinkle of nuts.

$14.00

Banana Cream Pie

*Blackberry Crumble

Our homemade blackberry pie, topped with a delicious crumble, is served year-round. We pick fresh blackberries from our farm and reserve them for our pies. *Berries from our farm.

$14.00

*Blackberry Crumble

*Blueberry Cream

Our Blueberry cream pie, made from scratch, is pure heaven in every bite. We use fresh blueberries picked right from our farm, and when combined with our creamy custard, it creates a simply delicious dessert. *Berries from our farm.

$14.00

*Blueberry Cream

Butterscotch

We top our homemade butterscotch pie with fresh, hand-whipped cream and a drizzle of caramel. Unlike store-bought versions, our butterscotch is crafted with wholesome ingredients, made right in our kitchen.

$14.00

Butterscotch

Cherry Pie

Our homemade flaky pie crust envelops a perfect balance of sweet and tart flavors in cherry pie.

$14.00

Cherry Pie

Chocolate Pie

Indulge in our delicious chocolate pie, made from scratch with a flaky crust and rich filling. It's topped with a sweet, fluffy topping and freshly grated chocolate, making every bite a delightful experience.

$14.00

Chocolate Pie

Coconut Cream Pie

Coconut cream pie combines a smooth, velvety coconut filling with a generous layer of light, fluffy whipped cream topping. It is topped with toasted coconut to add a little crunch to each bite.

$14.00

Coconut Cream Pie

Custard Pie

Our Creamy Custard Pie is a delightful dessert made with cream, sugar, eggs, and vanilla, topped with a sprinkle of cinnamon. Simple yet delicious, it’s sure to please anyone with a sweet tooth.

$14.00

Custard Pie

Derby Pie

Our scratch-made Derby pie offers a perfect blend of coconut, chocolate chips, and oatmeal. Enjoy it warm or cold for a simply delicious treat.

$14.00

Derby Pie

Dutch Apple

Indulge in our made-from-scratch Dutch Apple pie, perfectly sweet and crafted with fresh apples. Topped with a crumbly mix of sugar, cinnamon, butter, flour, and oats, it’s simply delicious—especially when you take it home and warm it up.

$14.00

Dutch Apple

Lemon Meringue

Our homemade flaky crust is filled with a delightful blend of sweet and tart lemon custard. And guess what? It’s topped with a fluffy meringue that you’ll absolutely love!

$14.00

Lemon Meringue

Peach Pie

Savor a summertime favorite year-round with this delicious peach pie. Enhance your experience by adding a dollop of whipped cream or a scoop of vanilla ice cream on top.

$14.00

Peach Pie

Pecan Pie

Indulge in our delightful Pecan Pie! Made with pecans, sugar, syrup, and a flaky crust, every slice is pure bliss. It’s perfectly sweet and baked to golden perfection. Treat yourself to this homestyle favorite.

$14.00

Pecan Pie

Peanut Butter Pie

Our creamy peanut butter pie filling features simple ingredients: peanut butter, sugar, cream, and butter. Combined and topped with fluffy whipped cream, it creates a delightful treat that will satisfy your sweet cravings.

$14.00

Peanut Butter Pie

Raisin Pie

Raisin pie, a cherished delicacy from Amish communities, is a must-try for pie enthusiasts. Our restaurant is one of the few places where you can enjoy freshly made raisin pie, making it a standout destination for dessert lovers.

$14.00

Raisin Pie

SUGAR FREE Dutch Apple

Our made-from-scratch, sugar-free Dutch Apple pie is perfectly sweet, featuring fresh apples and a crumbly topping of cinnamon, butter, flour, and oats. It’s delicious when warmed at home. When you pick it up, don't forget to add a quart of vanilla ice cream!

$17.00

SUGAR FREE Dutch Apple

SUGAR FREE Cherry Pie

SUGAR-FREE: Our cherry pie expertly balances sweet and tart flavors, all encased in a homemade flaky crust.

$17.00

SUGAR FREE Cherry Pie
Cakes

Cakes

All of our desserts are made from scratch at the restaurant. Our cakes are made from scratch with wholesome ingredients and freshly made buttercream or cream cheese frosting. Cakes serve 16

Coconut Cake

Light, fluffy white coconut-flavored cake topped with made-from-scratch buttercream frosting and coconut.

$28.00

Coconut Cake

Chocolate Cake

Indulge in our made-from-scratch double-layer chocolate cake, generously iced for a rich and delightful experience. Perfect for birthdays and special occasions, each cake serves 16 slices.

$28.00

Chocolate Cake

Carrot Cake

Indulge in our made-from-scratch cake featuring double layers of freshly grated carrots and chopped nuts, all topped with house-made cream cheese icing and additional nuts. Perfect for your next special occasion, our whole cake serves 16 slices.

$28.00

Carrot Cake

Angel Food

Indulge in our fluffy homemade cake, made with farm-fresh eggs, fine cake flour, and sugar for a melt-in-your-mouth experience. Choose to top it with whipped cream or one of our house-made fruit toppings. Order a cake for your next birthday or special occasion (16 slices).

$17.00

Angel Food

Butter Pecan Cake

Homemade butter pecan cake is a delightful treat that combines the rich, buttery flavor of the cake with crunchy, toasted pecans. Each slice is moist and fluffy, with a velvety whipped buttercream frosting that adds an extra layer of sweetness. It will surely please butter pecan lovers!

$28.00

Butter Pecan Cake
Baked Goods

Baked Goods

Delicious homemade bread, dinner rolls, and cinnamon rolls.

Loaf of White Bread

Made From Scratch White Bread is sliced and ready to eat. Don't forget our peanut butter spread.

$4.00

Loaf of White Bread

Loaf of Wheat Bread

Enjoy our delicious, made-from-scratch whole wheat bread—sliced and ready to eat! Pair it with a jar of our homemade peanut butter spread for a delightful treat!

$4.00

Loaf of Wheat Bread

Dozen White Dinner Rolls

Our white yeast rolls are kneaded and proofed right in our kitchen, ensuring they are fresh when baked just for you. They make a perfect addition to any meal, and you can reheat them to enjoy that fresh-from-the-oven perfection.

$6.00

Dozen White Dinner Rolls

Cinnamon Rolls

**Order a Pan of 8 Cinnamon Rolls!** These delicious, made-from-scratch breakfast treats are perfect for any occasion! Iced and ready to enjoy, you can either reheat them or dig in right away after unwrapping. Great for special events, luncheons, or just because! Treat yourself today! Pan of 8 Rolls.

$15.00

Cinnamon Rolls

Peanut Butter Spread

Try our sweet and creamy peanut butter spread, made from scratch! It’s the perfect complement to our fresh bread, adding a delightful boost to your snacks. Treat yourself to a mouthwatering delight! 1 pint

$8.00

Peanut Butter Spread

©2026 by Schwartz Family Restaurant

bottom of page